Upper West Side (Central)
Upper West Side (Central) is the better base for families and longer stays. Seven of the twelve listed hotels offer family rooms, seven have a gym and seven have parking, and six include a kitchen — a high share for Manhattan and useful if you plan to eat some meals in. The star mix runs five 4- and 5-star properties, two 3-star and five others, so there is real spread rather than a single tier.
Nearby, local listings count 45 restaurants and cafes, 11 bars and nightlife venues, six museums, galleries and sights, three shops and markets and one spa within half a kilometre of at least one hotel. That reflects the residential core around Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue, close to the American Museum of Natural History and Central Park's western edge. It is a neighbourhood for unhurried mornings, not late nights.
At a glance
Upper West Side (Central): 12 hotels, 5 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 45 restaurants and cafes, 11 bars and nightlife, 6 museums, galleries and sights.
Lincoln Square: 8 hotels, 4 of them 4 or 5 star; nearby in local listings (within 0.5 km): 62 restaurants and cafes, 15 bars and nightlife, 8 spas.
Lincoln Square
Lincoln Square suits travellers who want choice of food, drink and spa treatments on the doorstep. Local listings within half a kilometre of at least one hotel count 62 restaurants and cafes, 15 bars and nightlife venues, eight spas, eight museums, galleries and sights and eight shops and markets — more of everything than Central, though it sits about 2 km from Upper West Side (Central).
The hotel mix is smaller at eight properties but slightly more upscale at the top: four 4- and 5-star hotels, two 3-star and two others. Five of the eight offer breakfast and five have a gym, four have family rooms and four have parking — a lower family share than Central, so this is the weaker pick if you need connecting or extra-bed setups.
Which one to choose
Choose Upper West Side (Central) if you are travelling with children, staying more than a few nights, or want a kitchen and parking in the same building. The higher share of family rooms and the six hotels with kitchens make it easier to settle in, and the museum-and-park setting rewards slow days. Among the listed properties I would book The Wallace for its 4.7 guest rating across 370 reviews, with Hotel Beacon as the alternative if you want a larger, busier property with 4.4 from 1,333 reviews.
Choose Lincoln Square if food, bars and spa time matter more than floor space for children, or if you want the widest spread of restaurants within a short walk. The Mandarin Oriental New York, 5 stars and 4.6 from 1,652 reviews, is the strongest-rated listed hotel there; the Fairfield Inn & Suites New York Manhattan Central Park is the 3-star option at 4.1 from 1,697 reviews. The two districts are about 2 km apart, so the choice rarely affects a single day's sightseeing.
Practical notes on both districts
Both districts sit on the west side of Central Park, so a stay in either keeps the park, the museum corridor and the Hudson River waterfront within a reasonable walk. Lincoln Square's higher spa count — eight against one — is the clearest practical difference for travellers building a rest day into the trip. Central's one spa and heavier restaurant count in the other direction reflects its more residential streets.
Ten of the twelve Central hotels carry a guest rating, against seven of eight in Lincoln Square, so read the review counts as well as the score: the 4-star Arthouse Hotel New York City has 2,224 reviews at 4.1, while The Wallace at 4.7 has 370. Larger counts generally indicate more consistent recent experience.
Frequently asked questions
Which district is better for families? Upper West Side (Central), where 58% of listed hotels offer family rooms against 50% in Lincoln Square.
How far apart are they? About 2 km, a walkable or short taxi ride across the upper west side of Manhattan.
Where are the most restaurants nearby? Lincoln Square, with 62 restaurants and cafes listed within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, against 45 in Central.
Which has more spa options? Lincoln Square, with eight spas listed nearby against one in Central.
Which has more hotels to compare? Upper West Side (Central), with twelve listed properties against eight in Lincoln Square.
Which hotels have the highest listed guest ratings? The Wallace at 4.7 in Central and the Mandarin Oriental New York at 4.6 in Lincoln Square.
Do many hotels offer kitchens?
Which is better for a short city break? Lincoln Square if you want bars and restaurants nearby; Central if you want park and museum access with quieter evenings.
Related articles
Keep reading
Questions
How do I get to Upper West Side (Central) and Lincoln Square from the airport?
From John F. Kennedy International Airport, take the AirTrain to Jamaica Station and then the subway or Long Island Rail Road into Manhattan. From Newark Liberty International Airport, use the AirTrain to Newark Liberty International Airport Station and then NJ Transit. Taxis and ride-shares are also available; travel times vary with traffic.
Are there grocery stores or markets near the hotels?
Yes, both districts have grocery stores and markets. Upper West Side (Central) has three shops and markets within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, while Lincoln Square has eight. The residential streets around Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue in Central are especially convenient for everyday shopping.
Which district is quieter at night?
Upper West Side (Central) is generally quieter. It has 11 bars and nightlife venues within half a kilometre of at least one hotel, compared with 15 in Lincoln Square. Central's residential character makes it better for light sleepers or families with early bedtimes.
Can I walk between the two districts?
The route is straightforward along streets like Broadway or Amsterdam Avenue, and taxis or buses are also options if you prefer not to walk.
Do hotels in these districts typically include breakfast?
In Lincoln Square, five of the eight listed hotels offer breakfast. It is best to check individual hotel listings for breakfast details.
What is the best time of year to visit for park access?
Spring and autumn are ideal for enjoying Central Park, with mild temperatures and colourful scenery. Summer can be hot and humid, while winter is cold but less crowded. The park is open year-round, and both districts provide easy access to its western edge.
Are there family-friendly activities beyond the American Museum of Natural History?
Yes, the American Museum of Natural History is a major draw, but families can also explore Central Park's playgrounds, the Diana Ross Playground, and the nearby Children's Museum of Manhattan. The Hudson River waterfront offers paths for walking and cycling, and Lincoln Square has more restaurants for varied dining.
Which district has better access to public transportation?
Both districts are well served by subway lines. Bus service is also frequent in both areas.
